Filter

Cuisines
Select cuisines
Features
Select features

The Best 15 Restaurants in Ortley Beach, New Jersey (NJ), United States

Bakin` Bagels Ortley New Jersey
3.5
14 reviews

1906 Route 35 N, Ortley Beach, NJ 08751-1218, Ortley Beach

Its a breakfast place down the shore so of course it's crazy busy during the season but on the plus side it means the ba

Ortley Seafood Market
4.5
17 reviews

1905 Route 35 N, Ortley Beach, NJ 08751-1217, Ortley Beach

Best seafood on the island

New Capriccio By The Sea
3
3 reviews

2304 Route 35 1st Ave, Ortley Beach, NJ 08751, Ortley Beach

We are vacationing in Lavallette, NJ and walked over from the beach to buy some lunch at Jersey Tomato. I’m so glad we

Sunny Hunny
4
39 reviews

Route 35 N and 6td Avenue, Ortley Beach, NJ, Ortley Beach

I arrived with a Group of 6 at 10:50 Am. We made a reservation to make sure all went smoothe. After arrival We put our o